Doctor Who's Tragical History TourDoctor Who's Tragical History Tour
  • Nu-Who
    • Ncuti Gatwa
    • Jodie Whittaker
    • Peter Capaldi
    • Matt Smith
    • David Tennant
    • Christopher Eccleston
  • Tweeners
    • John Hurt
    • Paul McGann
    • The Master List
    • Regeneration X
    • The Mystery Guest
    • The Hand of Fear
  • Colo(u)r
    • Sylvester McCoy
    • Colin Baker
    • Peter Davison
    • Tom Baker
    • Jon Pertwee
  • Monochrome
    • Patrick Troughton
    • William Hartnell
  • Tour du Jour
    • On This Day
    • The House of Holmes
    • 50 for 50
    • The Randomizer
    • THT Rand-o-pix of the Day
    • The Feast of Steven
    • Tour Notz
    • The Watcher
    • Contact the Tour
X (Twitter) Instagram Tumblr RSS
Doctor Who's Tragical History Tour
X (Twitter) Instagram Tumblr RSS
  • Nu-Who
    1. Ncuti Gatwa
    2. Jodie Whittaker
    3. Peter Capaldi
    4. Matt Smith
    5. David Tennant
    6. Christopher Eccleston
    7. View All

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    The Next-iest of Doctors

    May 29, 2022

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    B-Bye Bradley

    October 6, 2022

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    Now You Sea Devil, No You Don’t

    April 24, 2022

    E-Spaced

    August 4, 2023

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    The Dark Jacket Dimension

    November 13, 2021

    Bad Hair Month

    September 9, 2021

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    E-Spaced

    August 4, 2023

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    The Wedding of SMW

    August 27, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    The Next-iest of Doctors

    May 29, 2022

    The Dark Jacket Dimension

    November 13, 2021

    The (W)hole Ruth

    January 31, 2020

    Ten Days Till the Tenthiversary of the Tenting of the Tenth

    December 22, 2019

    The Last ‘Last Christmas’ Specials Rankings #3

    December 24, 2018

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023
  • Tweeners
    1. John Hurt
    2. Paul McGann
    3. The Master List
    4. Regeneration X
    5. The Mystery Guest
    6. The Hand of Fear
    7. View All

    Hurt So Good: A Doctor and His Umbrella

    April 27, 2023

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    Ten’ll Get You Five

    September 4, 2020

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    McGann Before McGann

    May 26, 2023

    … And All That Yaz

    November 16, 2022

    Fivey at Forty: The First Companion Death of 1982

    March 16, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023

    Ghost Re-Write

    November 16, 2021

    The (W)hole Ruth

    January 31, 2020

    Dup-topia

    January 29, 2020

    The Glue Guy

    June 24, 2018

    Doctor on Doctor ACTION!

    November 19, 2017

    The Wheel in Cheese

    August 10, 2014

    The Hurt Locker

    May 25, 2013

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023
  • Colo(u)r
    1. Sylvester McCoy
    2. Colin Baker
    3. Peter Davison
    4. Tom Baker
    5. Jon Pertwee
    6. View All

    A Studio Film (or rather a film in the studio)

    June 9, 2023

    … And All That Yaz

    November 16, 2022

    Fivey at Forty: The First Companion Death of 1982

    March 16, 2022

    Roomba With a Prenumbra

    March 1, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    Hurt So Good: A Doctor and His Umbrella

    April 27, 2023

    … And All That Yaz

    November 16, 2022

    B-Bye Bradley

    October 6, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    The Inevitable Adric

    July 14, 2023

    The Box(ing) Day of Delights

    December 26, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023

    The Inevitable Adric

    July 14, 2023

    Hurt So Good: A Doctor and His Umbrella

    April 27, 2023

    McGann Before McGann

    May 26, 2023

    The Warrior Before Time

    May 19, 2023

    Purple Shag Carpet

    May 11, 2023

    Hurt So Good: A Doctor and His Umbrella

    April 27, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023
  • Monochrome
    1. Patrick Troughton
    2. William Hartnell
    3. View All

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    When Patrick (almost) Met Ian

    August 25, 2023

    When Patrick Met Verity

    August 11, 2023

    More For Letts

    July 25, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    When Patrick Met Verity

    August 11, 2023

    The TARDIS whirled on it’s way again…

    December 23, 2022

    Invasion of The Invasion

    December 17, 2022

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (54→49)

    September 20, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Prelude

    September 8, 2023

    Destiny of the Costume Closet

    September 1, 2023
  • Tour du Jour
    • On This Day
    • The House of Holmes
    • 50 for 50
    • The Randomizer
    • THT Rand-o-pix of the Day
    • The Feast of Steven
    • Tour Notz
    • The Watcher
    • Contact the Tour
Doctor Who's Tragical History TourDoctor Who's Tragical History Tour
Tour Updates

Is Half an Oaf Better Than None?

By -- DSWSeptember 7, 201402 Mins Read
Share
Twitter Tumblr

Mark Gatiss has done it again, though perhaps not in the way he intended.  Gatiss has enough of a track record by now in nu-Who that we can rate some of his stories against each other and have a healthy debate about it (hey that sounds like a mid-week mid-season list post–note to self).  While some of his stories are beloved, Victory of the Daleks was divisive and although not as pronounced, we suspect that Robot of Sherwood might also, and that rather depends on how you like your ‘legends’ presented to you.

The ‘celebrity historical’ has long been a fixture in Doctor Who going all the way back to Marco Polo.  In Robot of Sherwood we are presented with the full Robin Hood myth, an especially deliberate choice given the ongoing questioning about the nature of heroism that has run through the season, ticking off all the boxes of Robin in manner and dress.  It’s no wonder that the Doctor is skeptical of how-down-the-line it all seems to fit.  But it is this underlying and ongoing skepticism that we here at the Tour suspect might very well undermine the episode for some fans.

This Capaldi Doctor so stubbornly clings to his notions that something must be up with Robin that while at least initially it’s comedic, and the competition with Robin over Clara’s attention is well-served, after awhile it did start to wear thin, so much so that the moment when the Sheriff finally points out the flaw in the Doctor’s reasoning is a bit of a fizzle.

That said Jenna Coleman was amazing in Robot of Sherwood, and this season has served her very well.  Having her once again verbally fence with the antagonists of the week is a nice turn, and well realized.

Unlike Into the Dalek where images were hard to come by, this week we’re positively overflowing with medieval goodness.  The caps are also a treat.  BTW did you spot Patrick Troughton in Robot of Sherwood?  We sure did.

Next week … Listen up!

Short Hops:
  • Can't Get No Gatiss-faction
    Can't Get No Gatiss-faction
  • 3/23/2005
    3/23/2005
  • Kconk Kconk
    Kconk Kconk
New Who for You Tour Updates Peter Capaldi Patrick Troughton Jenna Coleman Marco Polo Robot of Sherwood Mark Gatiss Victory of the Daleks Series 8 Into the Dalek
Share. Twitter Tumblr
Previous ArticleSeconds Anyone?
Next Article The Series 8 Dynamic Ratings Table
Countdown to the 60th
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
Gallery Gateway

The David Tennant Galleries

John Hurt -- Who Not Who!

The William Hartnell Galleries

The Patrick Troughton Galleries

Ncuti Gatwa -- Who Not Who!

The Sylvester McCoy Galleries

The Tom Baker Galleries

The Jodie Whittaker Galleries

The Peter Capaldi Galleries

The Colin Baker Galleries

The Peter Davison Galleries

The Jon Pertwee Galleries

The Paul McGann Galleries

Who is The Mystery Guest?

The Christopher Eccleston Galleries

The Matt Smith Galleries

Last Ten Updated Galleries
  1. → Flux - Chapter 5: Survivors of the Flux
  2. → An Adventure in Space and Time
  3. → Smith and Jones
  4. → The Long Game
  5. → Genesis of the Daleks
  6. → Time-Flight
  7. → The Time Warrior
  8. → The Greatest Show in the Galaxy
  9. → Anthony Ainley -- Who Not Who!
  10. → Lalla Ward -- Who Not Who!
THT on Instagram
Tour Categories
  • Tour Updates (442)
  • New Who for You (167)
  • Roundel Roundabouts (224)
  • Tangential Tardis (43)
  • HD Re-classic-ation (31)
  • Modern Recap-itulation (42)
  • Classic Capitology (101)
  • Who Not Who! (31)
  • Xmas Marks the Spot (83)
  • 60 for 60 (3)
  • 50 for 50 (58)
  • Off the Reservation (16)
  • Ncuti Gatwa (3)
  • Jodie Whittaker (45)
  • Peter Capaldi (86)
  • Matt Smith (117)
  • David Tennant (112)
  • Christopher Eccleston (36)
  • John Hurt (14)
  • Paul McGann (27)
  • Sylvester McCoy (39)
  • Colin Baker (37)
  • Peter Davison (62)
  • Tom Baker (96)
  • Jon Pertwee (63)
  • Patrick Troughton (64)
  • William Hartnell (76)
  • Richard E Grant (7)
  • Jo Martin (3)
  • Series 13 (16)
  • Series 12 (13)
  • Series 11 (9)
  • Series 10 (21)
  • Series 9 (17)
  • Series 8 (25)
  • Series 7 (17)
  • Series 6 (20)
  • Series 5 (14)
  • Series 4 (25)
  • Series 3 (9)
  • Series 2 (15)
  • Series 1 (19)
On This Day in Doctor Who History
  • September 22
    • 1979: Destiny of the Daleks [4]
    • 2012: The Power of Three
  • September 23
    • 1978: The Ribos Operation [4]
    • 1967: The Tomb of the Cybermen [4]
  • September 24
    • 1977: The Horror of Fang Rock [4]
    • 1966: The Smugglers [3]
    • 2011: Closing Time
  • September 25
    • 1976: The Masque of Mandragora [4]
    • 1965: Galaxy 4 [3-- [Air Lock]
  • September 26
    • 2015: The Witch's Familiar
  • September 27
    • 2014: The Caretaker
    • 1975: Planet of Evil [1]
    • 1980: Meglos [1]
    • 1986: The Mysterious Planet [4]
    • 1989: Battlefield [4]
  • September 28
    • 1968: The Mind Robber [3]

Random Thoughts
6/18/2007
By -- DSWJune 18, 2007 Roundel Roundabouts 1 Min Read
7/25/2005
By -- DSWJuly 25, 2005 Roundel Roundabouts 1 Min Read
Year of the Cap Gap
By -- DSWApril 7, 2012 Tour Updates 2 Mins Read

  • x
  • instagram
  • tumblr
  • rss

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.