Close Menu
Doctor Who's Tragical History TourDoctor Who's Tragical History Tour
  • Nu-Who
    • Ncuti Gatwa
    • Jodie Whittaker
    • Peter Capaldi
    • Matt Smith
    • David Tennant
    • Christopher Eccleston
  • Tweeners
    • John Hurt
    • Paul McGann
    • The Master List
    • Regeneration X
    • The Mystery Guest
    • The Hand of Fear
  • Colo(u)r
    • Sylvester McCoy
    • Colin Baker
    • Peter Davison
    • Tom Baker
    • Jon Pertwee
  • Monochrome
    • Patrick Troughton
    • William Hartnell
  • Tour du Jour
    • On This Day in Doctor Who History
    • The House of Holmes
    • 60 for 60
    • 50 for 50
    • The Randomizer
    • THT Rand-o-pix of the Day
    • The Feast of Steven
    • Tour Notz
    • The Watcher
    • Contact the Tour
X (Twitter) Instagram Tumblr RSS
Doctor Who's Tragical History TourDoctor Who's Tragical History Tour
X (Twitter) Instagram Tumblr RSS
  • Nu-Who
    1. Ncuti Gatwa
    2. Jodie Whittaker
    3. Peter Capaldi
    4. Matt Smith
    5. David Tennant
    6. Christopher Eccleston
    7. View All

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025

    RTD Has His JN-T Moment

    April 20, 2025

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (24→19)

    November 10, 2023

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    B-Bye Bradley

    October 6, 2022

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    2024Kristmas #4 – Twice Upon the First

    December 21, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (18→13)

    November 13, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (36→31)

    October 12, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (42→37)

    October 5, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (12→7)

    November 17, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (24→19)

    November 10, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (30→25)

    October 28, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (48→43)

    September 28, 2023

    2024Kristmas #3 – The Man With All The Toys

    December 16, 2024

    2024Kristmas #2 – It’ll Be a Wild Blue Christmas

    December 10, 2024

    2024Kristmas #1 – Seasons Beastings

    December 3, 2024

    Pre-Embering the Fireplace

    May 5, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (24→19)

    November 10, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (42→37)

    October 5, 2023

    The Dark Jacket Dimension

    November 13, 2021

    The (W)hole Ruth

    January 31, 2020

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025
  • Tweeners
    1. John Hurt
    2. Paul McGann
    3. The Master List
    4. Regeneration X
    5. The Mystery Guest
    6. The Hand of Fear
    7. View All

    Hurt So Good: A Doctor and His Umbrella

    April 27, 2023

    Who Told You There Wouldn’t Be Any Math?

    December 5, 2022

    Svelte 16

    May 8, 2022

    Ten’ll Get You Five

    September 4, 2020

    Double Doctor Dastardly Danger

    April 25, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    McGann Before McGann

    May 26, 2023

    … And All That Yaz

    November 16, 2022

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025

    Ghost Re-Write

    November 16, 2021

    The (W)hole Ruth

    January 31, 2020

    Dup-topia

    January 29, 2020

    The Glue Guy

    June 24, 2018

    Doctor on Doctor ACTION!

    November 19, 2017

    The Wheel in Cheese

    August 10, 2014

    The Hurt Locker

    May 25, 2013

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025
  • Colo(u)r
    1. Sylvester McCoy
    2. Colin Baker
    3. Peter Davison
    4. Tom Baker
    5. Jon Pertwee
    6. View All

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (36→31)

    October 12, 2023

    A Studio Film (or rather a film in the studio)

    June 9, 2023

    … And All That Yaz

    November 16, 2022

    Fivey at Forty: The First Companion Death of 1982

    March 16, 2022

    Sweet, not Effete

    April 5, 2025

    Arguably Arguable

    August 19, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (48→43)

    September 28, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (60→55)

    September 15, 2023

    The End of Enlightenment

    January 13, 2025

    What’s in a Number? Occasionally Everything

    November 23, 2024

    A Spot of Gray in a Sea of Color

    November 19, 2024

    ⅔ of a Magic Number, but None Too Shabby Either

    October 1, 2024

    The Truth That Supports the Lie

    March 15, 2025

    The Golden Sweep of Tom Baker Begins

    December 28, 2024

    Déjà Who, All Over Again

    February 8, 2024

    XCited for Tom

    January 27, 2024

    Living Day-to-Day with The Candy Man

    July 31, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (6→1)

    November 23, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (30→25)

    October 28, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (48→43)

    September 28, 2023

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025
  • Monochrome
    1. Patrick Troughton
    2. William Hartnell
    3. View All

    Stock(s) Company

    September 9, 2024

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (18→13)

    November 13, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (24→19)

    November 10, 2023

    60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (36→31)

    October 12, 2023

    The TARDIS whirled on it’s way again…

    December 24, 2024

    Have a Feast @ Doctor Who’s Tragical History Tour!

    December 6, 2024

    Quarter Zip

    July 21, 2024

    Roll Without the Rock, or the Schlock

    July 15, 2024

    The Demon Barber of Story Beats

    May 12, 2025

    The Bearable Light-ness of Doctoring

    May 10, 2025

    The Sunday Stratagem

    May 4, 2025

    Five Regenerations Past Midnight

    April 27, 2025
  • Tour du Jour
    • On This Day in Doctor Who History
    • The House of Holmes
    • 60 for 60
    • 50 for 50
    • The Randomizer
    • THT Rand-o-pix of the Day
    • The Feast of Steven
    • Tour Notz
    • The Watcher
    • Contact the Tour
Doctor Who's Tragical History TourDoctor Who's Tragical History Tour
Tour Updates New Who for You Matt Smith Series 5

Not the Boneyard, Scrapyard or Knacker’s Yard

By -- DSWMay 16, 201002 Mins Read
Share
Twitter Tumblr

Amy’s Choice is a sneaky, sneaky beast.  Quite likely not tilting towards the populist end of Doctor Who stories and instead into more of the esoteric, the first viewing of this story with it’s laconic pacing and lack of the “monster” per se was merely “whelming.”  A second, and it has to be said, more alert viewing, brought all sorts of revelations, most notably the nifty plotting and the amazing performances of Toby Jones and Karen Gillan.  Perhaps what satisfied most wholly was the revelation that Dream Lord was in fact the Doctor himself, admittedly under the influence of “psychic pollen.”  Since this is becoming a season for callbacks, both obvious and oblique, we loved this variation on The Ultimate Foe, Robert Holmes’ last contribution to the series was the idea that the Valeyard was a dark distillation of the Doctor, somewhere between the last and next to last incarnation.

The joy in this story, owing to Toby Jones’ performance, is what a mean-spirited imp the Dream Lord is, always being derogatory and yet playful as well to the Doctor at the same time.  The story also advanced, in a much more satisfying way, the Doctor-Rory-Amy triangle, begun in The Vampires of Venice.  Last week we said Rory was fairing better than the Tin Dog, and he’s certainly no Adam either, this is a threesome that has the dynamics that, at least for this fan, go back to Season 12 and Sarah Jane and Harry.  High praise indeed.

As a result of all this we’ve put this episode at the top of the 2010 Dynamic Ratings Table.  How ’bout you?

Images and caps for Amy’s Choice are now online.

Short Hops:

60 for 60 — The Greatest Stories in Doctor Who History — (30→25) Ten for the Teens So Long and Thanks for All the Fish
The Vampires of Venice Series 5 New Who for You Tour Updates Karen Gillan Matt Smith Arthur Darvill Amy's Choice Robert Holmes The Ultimate Foe
Share. Twitter Tumblr
Previous ArticleSo Long and Thanks for All the Fish
Next Article A Little Birdie Told Me …
‘Wish World’ begins in …
0
Years
:
0
Months
:
0
Days
:
0
Hrs
:
0
Mins
:
0
Secs
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
Gallery Gateway

Jo Martin

Colin Baker

Ncuti Gatwa

Tom Baker

Patrick Troughton

Richard E Grant

Jon Pertwee

The Master List

Jodie Whittaker

Paul McGann

David Tennant

Peter Capaldi

Matt Smith

William Hartnell

Peter Davison

Sylvester McCoy

John Hurt

Christopher Eccleston

THT on Instagram
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day THT Rand-o-Pix of the Day
Series 15 Dynamic Ratings Table
  1. 1. The Story & The Engine
  2. 2. The Well
  3. 3. Lucky Day
  4. 4. The Robot Revolution
  5. 5. Joy to the World
  6. 6. Lux
On This Day in Doctor Who History

May 2025

Sunday May 18

1968: The Wheel in Space [4]
Recurs yearly
1974: Planet of the Spiders [3]
Recurs yearly
2013: The Name of the Doctor
Recurs yearly
2024: Boom
Recurs yearly

Monday May 19

1973: The Green Death [1]
Recurs yearly
2007: 42
Recurs yearly

Tuesday May 20

1967: The Evil of the Daleks [1]
Recurs yearly
1972: The Time Monster [1]
Recurs yearly
2006: The Age of Steel
Recurs yearly
2017: Extremis
Recurs yearly

Wednesday May 21

1966: The Gunfighters [4--The OK Corral]
Recurs yearly
2005: The Empty Child
Recurs yearly
2011: The Rebel Flesh
Recurs yearly

Thursday May 22

1965: The Chase [1--The Executioners]
Recurs yearly
1971: The Dæmons [1]
Recurs yearly
Random Thoughts

Regeneration X

By -- DSWOctober 7, 2010 Tangential Tardis 2 Mins Read

60 for 60 — The Prelude

By -- DSWSeptember 8, 2023 60 for 60 2 Mins Read

Golden Master

By -- DSWJanuary 23, 2021 Tour Updates 2 Mins Read
X (Twitter) Instagram Tumblr RSS
Last Ten Updated Galleries
  1. ► The Interstellar Song Contest -- Screen Captures
  2. ► The Interstellar Song Contest
  3. ► The David Tennant Miscellany
  4. ► Meglos
  5. ► The Story and the Engine -- Screen Captures
  6. ► The Story and the Engine
  7. ► The Colin Baker Miscellany
  8. ► City of Death
  9. ► The Giggle
  10. ► Planet of Fire
Tour Categories
  • Tour Updates (484)
  • New Who for You (187)
  • Roundel Roundabouts (240)
  • Tangential Tardis (41)
  • HD Re-classic-ation (45)
  • Modern Recap-itulation (46)
  • Classic Capitology (101)
  • Who Not Who! (42)
  • Xmas Marks the Spot (86)
  • 60 for 60 (11)
  • 50 for 50 (58)
  • Off the Reservation (16)
  • Ncuti Gatwa (22)
  • Jodie Whittaker (46)
  • Peter Capaldi (91)
  • Matt Smith (121)
  • David Tennant (126)
  • Christopher Eccleston (38)
  • John Hurt (14)
  • Paul McGann (28)
  • Sylvester McCoy (40)
  • Colin Baker (40)
  • Peter Davison (71)
  • Tom Baker (107)
  • Jon Pertwee (67)
  • Patrick Troughton (68)
  • William Hartnell (88)
  • Richard E Grant (7)
  • Jo Martin (3)
  • Series 15 (5)
  • Series 14 (20)
  • Series 13 (16)
  • Series 12 (13)
  • Series 11 (9)
  • Series 10 (21)
  • Series 9 (17)
  • Series 8 (25)
  • Series 7 (17)
  • Series 6 (20)
  • Series 5 (14)
  • Series 4 (25)
  • Series 3 (9)
  • Series 2 (15)
  • Series 1 (19)

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.